In some constitutions, do the "ruffians" feature in the first degree itself?
Yes, in some Masonic constitutions, the characters referred to as "ruffians" do indeed feature in the first degree, known as the Entered Apprentice degree. These figures are not literal individuals but symbolic characters within the ritual. They represent the forces of ignorance, malice, and opposition that a candidate must overcome on their journey of moral and spiritual development.
The presence of these symbolic "ruffians" in the first degree serves to illustrate the challenges and temptations that can hinder a Mason's progress. Their defeat signifies the triumph of virtue, reason, and brotherly love over these negative influences. This dramatic element underscores the importance of integrity and the commitment to a higher moral standard from the very outset of a Mason's journey.